Karen Read Retrial: Key Developments from the Week of June 2, 2025

The retrial of Karen Read, accused of second-degree murder in the 2022 death of Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe, saw significant developments this week that could influence the jury's perspective.

Defense Highlights Alternative Theories

A pivotal moment came with the testimony of snowplow driver Brian "Lucky" Loughran. He stated that between 2:40 and 6:00 a.m. on the morning O’Keefe's body was discovered, he made multiple passes by 34 Fairview Road in Canton but did not see a body in the snow. This challenges the prosecution's timeline that O’Keefe was left outside for hours during a blizzard. Loughran also noted seeing a Ford Edge SUV parked unusually in front of the house, which he found odd given the homeowners' typical parking habits.

Dr. Marie Russell, a forensic pathologist specializing in dog bites, testified that wounds on O’Keefe's arm were consistent with dog scratches, not injuries from a vehicle. This supports the defense's theory that O’Keefe may have been attacked inside the house by a dog, rather than being struck by Read's SUV.

Additionally, surveillance footage from the Waterfall Bar and Grille showed a tense exchange between O’Keefe and ATF Agent Brian Higgins shortly before the incident. Read claimed she did not notice the confrontation, as she was engaged in conversation with a friend at the time .

Courtroom Dynamics and Witness Testimonies

Former Canton Police Officer Kelly Dever testified that she initially told federal investigators she saw Higgins and Canton Police Chief Kenneth Berkowitz near Read’s SUV for an extended period, suggesting possible tampering. However, Dever later retracted this statement on the stand, claiming it was a "false memory" and that she was pressured and threatened with perjury charges by the defense. The defense challenged her credibility, with attorney Alan Jackson referring to her as "Officer Diva" during cross-examination.

On Friday, Dr. Daniel Wolfe, a crash reconstruction expert from ARCCA, testified about the damage to Read’s SUV and whether it was consistent with the injuries sustained by O’Keefe. His analysis is crucial in determining the plausibility of the prosecution's claim that Read struck O’Keefe with her vehicle.

Aidan 'Turtleboy' Kearney's Involvement

Aidan Kearney, known as "Turtleboy," has been a vocal supporter of Read, alleging a cover-up by local law enforcement. He has faced multiple charges, including witness intimidation and wiretapping, related to his involvement in the case. Recently, Kearney was indicted on additional charges after an incident at a pizza shop owned by trial witnesses.

During Loughran's testimony, the prosecution questioned whether he felt threatened by Kearney, who had contacted him and posted their conversation online. Loughran denied feeling intimidated, stating he was unaware the call was being recorded.

Kearney's aggressive tactics have drawn criticism and legal scrutiny, with District Attorney Michael Morrissey condemning the harassment of witnesses and the spread of conspiracy theories . to the case.

There have been some reports that “Turtleboy” might be willing to cut a deal.

Looking Ahead

As the trial progresses, the defense continues to present evidence challenging the prosecution's narrative, focusing on alternative theories and potential misconduct by law enforcement. The jury's interpretation of these testimonies and the credibility of witnesses will be pivotal in determining the outcome of this high-profile case.